Skip to content
Codex of Light

Light Seen / Pass 2

The second pass falls under the Spiral Moon, still in Iphi. Its sign is the spiral, the shape of growth that keeps its form.

Schematic. A beam with a twisted wavefront. The beam travels straight; its phase winds around the axis.
Schematic. A beam with a twisted wavefront. The beam travels straight; its phase winds around the axis.

The light

The reflection says that light propagates in spirals, not straight lines. This is the claim in the reflection that physics most plainly contradicts, and it is also the one with the most surprising near-truth.

The place

On Fajada Butte in Chaco Canyon, New Mexico, three great slabs of rock lean against a cliff. Behind them the ancestral Pueblo people carved a spiral. In 1977 the artist Anna Sofaer saw that at midday on the summer solstice a thin blade of sunlight came between the slabs and cut the spiral through its centre. At the winter solstice two blades held it on either side. The site is known as the Sun Dagger. The slabs have since shifted, and the blade no longer falls as it did.

What is known

In empty space light travels in straight lines. Euclid wrote it down about 300 BC. Ibn al-Haytham proved it by experiment in Cairo a thousand years ago, with a dark room and a small hole. Pierre de Fermat added in 1662 that between two points light takes the path of least time. Every shadow, every eclipse and every camera depends on this. Gravity can bend light's path, as Einstein predicted and an eclipse confirmed in 1919, but that is a curve in space, not a spiral.

What can turn is not the path but the wave. In circularly polarised light the electric force rotates as the wave advances, so that its tip traces a helix. And in 1992 Les Allen and his colleagues in Leiden showed that a beam can be made whose whole wavefront is twisted like a corkscrew. Such "twisted light" carries a turning force, and it can spin a small particle caught in it. It is now used in microscopes and in experiments on sending information.

The golden spiral has no place in any of this. It is a figure of growth, found approximately in some shells and seed heads, and it is not the shape of a light wave.

There is one more spiral, and it has just been redrawn. Moths circling a lamp were long said to fly a spiral because they held a fixed angle to the light, as if it were the Moon. In 2024 a team filming insects in three dimensions found something simpler. An insect keeps its back toward the brightest part of the sky. A lamp near the ground confuses that reflex, and the insect banks around it, trapped.

What is seen

A straight beam. A blade of light crossing a carved spiral.

What is unseen

The twist inside a beam that looks perfectly straight. Nobody guessed it for most of the history of optics, and it was there to be made all along.

The geometry beneath

A straight line for the path; a helix for the phase. The two are not in conflict. A corkscrew has an axis, and the axis is straight.

Claim or readingGradeWhat the evidence shows
Light propagates in spirals, not straight linesnot supportedStraight-line travel is the basis of all optics
Light can carry a twistestablishedCircular polarisation; twisted beams since 1992
The golden spiral is the path of lightnot supportedNo measurement shows it
The Sun Dagger marked the solstices on a carved spiralestablished as an event; intent is likely but unrecordedSofaer's records from 1977 on
Insects spiral to a lamp by navigating on itcontested, now doubtfulThe 2024 study points to a tilting reflex
The spiral is the Monad's breath in lightsymbolicThe reading of this study

Near-truths

  • Light does not travel in a spiral. It can be given one, and it keeps it.
  • The people of Chaco did not bend the light. They placed a spiral where straight light would find it, twice a year.
  • A straight path and a turning heart can belong to the same beam.
Practice: Straight and Turning

With a finger, draw a slow spiral in the air in front of you, outward on the in-breath.

On the out-breath, draw it back to the centre.

Then point the finger straight ahead, and keep it still for one breath.

Notice that the spiral had a centre line all the time.

Rest, and breathe normally.